US: Jobs report not the smoking gun for a December hike – Danske Bank

Senior Analyst, Mikael Olai Milhøj at Danske Bank, notes that the US nonfarm payrolls rose 156,000 in September, in line with Danske Bank’s expectations of 160,000 but below consensus of 172,000.

Key Quotes

“There were no big revisions to the last two months (combined -7,000). Thus it seems that the strong jobs reports in the summer were mainly due to the weakness in the spring. Employment growth was driven by the service sector, while manufacturing employment fell again. Overall, employment growth has slowed this year.

On average, nonfarm payrolls have risen 180,000 per month, below the average increase in both 2015 (230,000), 2014 (250,000) and 2013 (190,000). While this may be due to the fact that we are not far from full employment, it may also be a lagged effect from the economic slowdown as GDP growth has slowed to around 1% q/q AR the past three quarters. Still, September marked the six year anniversary of the job recovery.

The details reveal there is still slack left in the labour market as the unemployment rate rose from 4.9% to 5.0% and the underemployment rate (a broader unemployment measure) was unchanged at 9.7%. The higher unemployment rate despite increasing employment is due to an increasing labour force. While it is positive that more workers are returning to the labour force (perhaps due to better employment prospects), it is also a sign that there was slacker in the labour market than previously thought. The underemployment rate has stopped declining and has been more or less constant over the last 12 months. This broader unemployment measure has previously been one of Yellen’s favourite slack measures.

It is also clear that we have not closed the unemployment gap when looking at wage growth, which continues to be subdued from a historical perspective. In September, average hourly earnings rose 0.2% m/m, implying an annual growth rate of 2.6% y/y. The weak wage growth is not only due to weak productivity growth but also due to remaining labour market slack. With subdued wage growth it is less likely that core inflation will move higher towards the Fed’s 2% target.

Overall, the September jobs report was not the ‘smoking gun’ for the Fed. For now we stick to our non-consensus view that the Fed will stay on hold until H1 17, although it is a close call whether the Fed will hike or not in December. The reason for our call is that the Fed seems too optimistic on Q3 GDP growth and we fear that economic data may disappoint in the short-term. The combination of weak GDP growth over the past three quarters, still slack left in the labour market, subdued wage growth, low inflation expectations and core inflation still below 2%, means that the Fed can afford to stay patient. A November hike seems unlikely due to the Presidential election just a week after the next FOMC meeting. Markets have priced in a two-thirds probability of a hike by the turn of the year.

This week we get retail sales in September, FOMC minutes from September and Yellen is speaking. All three could be important for our Fed call.”